Sisters allegedly sexually assault man with pliers, force him to drink urine

Categories: Weird Wisconsin
Bartkey.jpg
Valerie Bartkey
In October, sisters Valerie Bartkey, 24, and Amanda Johnson, 17, both of Somerset, allegedly forced a man to undress, twisted his penis with pliers, and forced him to drink their urine.

The victim later told authorities that the penis twisting was the most painful thing he's ever experienced.
 
The Pioneer Press reports that the 18-year-old victim found himself at a residence in the sisters' hometown of Somerset when they began punching and kicking him. After the beatdown, the sisters brought the victim a yellow-colored beverage to drink. They told him it was lemonade. Only after the victim took a sip did he realize the sour-tasting liquid was actually one or both of the sisters' urine.
Valerie-M-Bartkey_mugshot.400x800.jpg
Another Bartkey mug from a previous arrest.


After beating him and forcing him to drink pee, the sisters told the man to undress. One of the sisters said they wanted to have sex with him. But instead, Johnson allegedly threatened the victim with a belt while Bartkey sexually assaulted him with pliers.

Following the incident, the sisters must've been worried the victim would eventually go to police, as Johnson allegedly called him later in the month and threatened him, saying she would tell authorities he smoked marijuana during the nightmare threesome. The man told authorities that although he didn't smoke weed during the evening from hell, both of the sisters did.

Both Bartkey and Johnson are charged with a felony count of second-degree sexual assault by force and misdemeanor counts of battery and criminal damage to property. Johnson is also charged with a misdemeanor count of intimidating a victim. The felony count has a maximum penalty of 25 years in prison.

My Voice Nation Help
54 comments
dshkflsdgs
dshkflsdgs

Could have been worse. A man's foreskin has 8x more sexual pleasure nerves than a woman's clitoris and is therefore also 8x more sensitive. Imagine if they strapped him down and then cut off his foreskin... Ouch.

Would have been 1000x more painful than this plier torture they put him through.

Donkey Hotay
Donkey Hotay

Who said marijuana users aren't violent ?

Bonnie Havis
Bonnie Havis

I don't feel the writer owes anyone an apology.  What makes this story stand out, not only as journal worthy, but as a target for humor is the fact that he is a male.  Unless he was physically handicapped, which was not indicated, then I find it bizarre that a grown man can be physically and sexually assualted by two women.  I have two adult sons, and I promise you this would not be physically possible with either one of them unless they were knocked out by force or chloraformed.  There was no mention of a gun or any other weapon nor of him being physically restrained.  He could have left at anytime.  It just says repeatedly that he was "forced".   If you read between the lines, which isn't difficult to do, then you would realize there is more to the story.  He probably went to their house willingly not "found himself at their residence" (what did he just fall out of the sky and land in their house?) hoping to get high and laid, and got embarrassed because they "played" him.  For revenge he called the police on them, opening himself up to further embarrassment and possibly a drug charge.  I find this hilarious because obviously this guy is an idiot. 

9576
9576

they also failed to mention that the 18 year old boy is mentally disabled....

J
J

I can't imagine how this story would've read had it been two males tieing up a retarded woman, forcing her to drink piss, then cutting off her clitoris with garden shears.

I'm not easily offended, but c'mon. This article reeks.

Morgiefagerland
Morgiefagerland

Two of those kids go to my school. That's sickness anyone who thinks its sexy is f***** messed up

VivlianWozz
VivlianWozz

I am a 27 years old doctor,mature and beautiful. and now i am seeking a good man who can give me real love, so i got a sername Andromeda2002 on  Agedate.СòM, a nice and free place for younger women and older men,or older women and younger men, to interact with each other.Maybe you wanna check out or tell your friends.

Blingprincess24
Blingprincess24

omigoodness... i knew the 17 year old girl. she was a few grades beneath me in high school and she was soooo annoying and loud, drove me crazy!! I really really did not like her, but I can't believe this happened. Poor boy :(

zenghooo
zenghooo

OK wow thats messed up man, and they be fugly!Total-Privacy dot US

Gracia
Gracia

NO SHIT HERE I GO TO SCHOOL WITH AMANDA JOHNSON.

Sad
Sad

The boy was autistic and molested as a child FYI.

guest
guest

The kid that they did this to has a lot of mental problems. Its a very sad story. Leave him alone, its not funny.

Tracy Reid
Tracy Reid

As an attorney for abuse victims, I am appalled at the flippant manner in which this author has referred to genital mutilation, sexual and physical assault, and intimidating a victim of very serious criminal activity.  Would the article have taken this tone if this were a woman beaten and sexually assaulted in such a manner?  Articles like this only serve to intimidate male victims of assault further.

Tracy Reid Cooper & Reid, LLC

jp
jp

As usual, you never disappoint citypages.  You just keep reaffirming your status as the worst journalists in the metro area.  Whoever's desk this pathetic excuse of an article got past should be fired.  Are you able to laugh this one off because it happened to a male?  If this happened to a female, you'd be calling for the man's head.  I still can't quite figure out why I waste my time with you, but something keeps bringing me back.  I guess I just enjoy the shit-show, and the beyond stupid comments made by the person that needs to get out of the basement and back into the real world, better known as Michelle Bachmann(because you couldn't come up with anything on your own), kinda like your thoughts on anything political, robot.

woefatcat
woefatcat

And to think I pay good money for these services and they are free in Wisconsin. Damn!

seriously?
seriously?

Wow. I'm incredibly disgusted by how you choose to present this article. "Kinky, threesome, throwing in a comical "'ol".  This happened to an 18 year old. Why are you presenting this as some light-hearted, humorous story? It isn't kinky, it wasn't a threesome, it was sexual assault. Would you have taken this tone if it had been a women being tortured?

Research
Research

They smoked weed and forgot the safety word he kept yelling.

Focus....
Focus....

If the camera adds a couple of lbs. to a picture, I wonder how many camera's were pointing at her during her last mug shot???

Michelle Bachmann
Michelle Bachmann

Kids today!   Back in my day twisting a penis with pliers was more of a 4th date type of thing. 

dshkflsdgs
dshkflsdgs

The most bias, condescending and apathetic comment I have ever read.

AVoiceForMen
AVoiceForMen

Holy Fuck Bonnie you must be a femninazi to actually believe this...off to the registry you go, along with the author of this article: www.register-her.com

Joshua
Joshua

So... you're saying he was asking for it?

<3
<3

He has special needs. Dont believe it? I know first hand. If you dont know the whole story keep your rude comments to yourself and get a life.

salmon
salmon

He is not all there

Drowondrums
Drowondrums

Bonnie Harris you are a waste of human life. it CAN happen to men. you just dont want to acknowlege the fact that women can be violent and do horrible acts. just because he is a man doesnt mean he is big and tough. Women like you really shouldnt have reproductive rights let alone a computer.

Guest
Guest

New richmond too

dshkflsdgs
dshkflsdgs

@Tracy Reid Look, it could have been worse. At least they didn't cut off his foreskin. Considering it's more sensitive and nerve riddled than the entire rest of the body combined, and considering it has 8x more nerves than a clitoris I'm quite positive if they circumcised him it would have been 1000x more painful and traumatizing. And because he's not a child his brain would have not blocked out his memory and he would have been in a world of hurt.

Look at the glass half full.

woefatcat
woefatcat

Can you explain to me why it is that if a man where to have done this to a woman he would get a 150 year sentence thrown at him but our justice system decides a woman rapist should get probation or maybe a few months? Why do you want journos to be fair when the whole system that you work in is a cesspool of double standards and prosecutorial misconduct? I mean sure, Aaron may well be a hack, but when you take the only tool he has left, immature humor, you might as well twist his balls with, dare I say, pliers?

atrupar
atrupar

Tracy and others -- I agree with your concerns. I got carried away in trying to make the piece funny and lost sight of the fact that I was writing about a very serious sexual assault. I've gone back, removed the flippant descriptions and presented the story in a way where hopefully the facts speak for themselves.

As you know, we aren't exactly known as a bastion of political correctness and like to stir the pot sometimes, but I agree that this crossed the line. It's something I'll remember moving forward. I do appreciate your thoughtful comments.

Michelle Bachmann
Michelle Bachmann

I’m livin’ in the 21st century

Doin’ something mean to it

Do it better than anybody you ever seen do it

Screams from the haters, got a nice ring to it

Research
Research

BTW, I feel that way towards wcco. Don't know why I go there.  CP might joke and what not but at least they dig into the story and give the details.   

Herb Dickerson
Herb Dickerson

don't be hating the playas in the basement jp,  hate the game.  

Michelle Bachmann
Michelle Bachmann

Great point.  There is nothing comical about this story at all.

woefatcat
woefatcat

Seriously. That was some funny shit. Did you ever wonder why after they gave him a refreshment that he still undressed? Most likely it was the offer of some trim. So if you are going to be mad at someone be mad at the dude who thinks with his dick....or just be mad at his dick.....Seriously.

jp
jp

You are a horrible journalist, if we can even call you that.  Get the facts before you try to put your liberal spin on it.  You are the 99%, right?  Again, how did you get your job?  It is now my goal to get your horrible journalistic ass fired.  You don't deserve to put your worthless opinion out there.

woefatcat
woefatcat

What an EPIC cave! And this is why I will never read another article of yours again.

jp
jp

I'm guessing you stole that from someone else too?  C'mon, your own thoughts please!

jp
jp

Dig into the story?   Really? Yeah, they're some real go-getters!   Wow, you live a sheltered life if you believe what you just wrote...

Guest
Guest

Your a F--k Head to.A storie like this and the non reaction [funny ,ya right] is way I'm getting harder[not feeling bad] when I here a woman getting raped or molested.If it happens to a male it funny[or mentality is he deservse-it,the dog]I think it is SICK raping ect and would never think of doing it but women's thinking and the laws over protecting if a women just yells RAPE for spite.And don't tell me its never happened.

Sierra
Sierra

first of all dip shit, the man has some serious mental issues. and second of all they are both majorly fucked up and they didn't "offer" it to him. they beat the shit out of him and forced him to drink it. maybe you need to get your facts straight before you start posting shit.

CapnBetty
CapnBetty

HAHAHA!  Keep WISCONSIN weird!

Dacoty
Dacoty

JP, you need to set yourself some different goals! Go live your life, you've only got one.

Michelle Bachmann
Michelle Bachmann

You don't know the lyrics of one of the most massively popular songs from the past 5 years.  You are an old nerd. 

jp
jp

Great comment, dumbass(Michele Bachmann)  Just kneel down and accept defeat.  You and your pathetic liberal spin on every single issue is a waste of time.  You know you can't win this one, and the only way you can try to make yourself feel worthy is by hating on everyone that doesn't think the way you do.  OBAMA 2012!!!!

Now Trending

From the Vault

 

Loading...