Brian Johnson, Pride Fest Bible hander-outer, loses federal court case

Categories: GLBT, Law
Brian Johnson and family.jpg
Brian Johnson, center, along with his son and wife at the Pride Fest in 2009.
Going to Pride Fest later this month? You shouldn't have to worry about Brian Johnson offering you a Bible.

Yesterday, Chief U.S. District Judge Michael Davis denied Johnson's request for an injunction that would've allowed him to again stroll around the Pride Fest and hand out his Bibles, unencumbered. The ruling means the Hayward, Wisconsin native will have to content himself with setting up shop in the festival's 'no pride zone,' which is an area where individuals and groups advocating causes that Pride deems inconsistent with its mission can hand out materials.

But Nate Kellum, chief counsel with the Center for Religious Freedom and Johnnson's lead attorney, said in a statement that other legal options are being explored.

"We are certainly disappointed in this ruling that fails to take Mr. Johnson's First Amendment freedoms into account," Kellum wrote. "Mr. Johnson should be allowed to hand out Bibles in a public area during a public festival and not be relegated to a 'no pride' zone where nobody bothers to go. Without an audience, Mr. Johnson is utterly deprived of his right to free speech."
Thumbnail image for rainbowflag crop.jpg
Johnson remains free to walk around the Pride Fest and chat with whoever he pleases, but has to keep his Bibles in the "no pride zone.'

Johnson has handed out Bibles at Pride Fest for years. That changed in 2009, when he was denied a booth, showed up anyway to get his message out, and was arrested. The next year, the Park Board approved Johnson's request to be in the park, but said he'd be arrested if he was disruptive. Last year, Pride Fest organizers and the Park Board penned Johnson in with the new 'no pride zone' policy, prompting the federal lawsuit.

In a 2010 City Pages profile, Johnson said his Christianity-promoting activities at the Pride Fest are not about confrontation. "I just want to shake someone's hand, look them in the eye, and tell them Jesus loves them," he said. He's still free to do that this year, but just won't be able to hand folks a Bible after he talks to them about Christ.

This year, the 'no prize zone' will be set up at Oak Grove Street and Lyndale Avenue, an intersection near one of the park's main entrances that should see lots of foot traffic. Judge Davis noted the zone's prime location in his ruling, debunking Kellum's notion that Johnson will be exiled to an untraveled corner of the festival.

Wrote Davis: "When the government seeks to regulate the time, place or manner of speech in a public forum and does so in a content-neutral manner, its actions are constitutional so long as they are narrowly tailored to serve a significant interest and allow alternative channels of communication."

Previous coverage:
-- Brian Johnson, Pride Fest Bible hander-outer, files federal lawsuit over "no pride zone" policy [UPDATE]
-- Pride Fest loses court fight; anti-gay evangelist allowed in Loring Park
-- Brian Johnson hands out bibles at Pride Fest with a smile
My Voice Nation Help
11 comments
TxWranglr
TxWranglr

"Without an audience, Mr. Johnson is utterly deprived of his right to free speech."

 

Typical of the right to interpret the Constitution to MANDATE AN AUDIENCE.

Joe
Joe

Really?  Seriously?  THAT's your answer? Do you have a progressive and inoperable brain condition Kirk? Every single one of your posts gets incrementally dumber and more histrionic.

Andy H.
Andy H.

Kirk, as usual you’re missing the point.  Liberals are generally more tolerant of ALL members of society.  That tolerance definitely attracts a high percentage of the gay community as well as large percentages of most minority groups.  You will also find that even though most functions the gay community organizes are met with some degree of bigoted protest they rarely if ever return the favor.  I believe the god followers would call that “turning the other cheek” or is it “do unto others”…ironic

Kirk the Conservative Jerk
Kirk the Conservative Jerk

 Do gays typically vote liberal?  Arn't liberals typically afraid to offend the Islamic faith? I gonna head down to my ex-wives Mosque this afternoon and see if they wont do just that. We will find out.

Andy H.
Andy H.

There’s that aforementioned hate/discrimination we were talking about Kirk.  I would have appreciated a bit more zeal to your argument, but instead…nothing.  That’s ok, I’m sure you’ll do better at the next opportunity to insert your brand of “sensibility”.

hunter
hunter

Do you think you could construct a weaker strawman? 

Joe
Joe

What makes you think it would be any different?

Logicplz
Logicplz

"Without an audience, Mr. Johnson is utterly deprived of his right to free speech." Lunacy. Your right to free speech does not hinge on whether people pay attention to you.

Now Trending

From the Vault

 

Loading...