Taylor Watson acquitted in controversial "too drunk to consent?" rape case

Categories: Law
taylor watson rect.jpeg
Watson told authorities the woman consented, but earlier, he allegedly told a friend something different entirely.
Yesterday, a Rice County jury acquitted Taylor Watson of all charges stemming from a sexual encounter he had with a very drunk female friend last April.

-- Roger Rivard, Wisconsin lawmaker: "Some girls, they rape so easy"
-- Wisconsin Lt. Gov. Rebecca Kleefisch: "There is a way to have a more 'forcible rape'" [VIDEO]

On that night, an 18-year-old woman -- Watson's friend and onetime lover years ago -- crashed at his Faribault apartment after drinking eight beers in a two-to-three hour period. While she lay in a drunken stupor on Watson's futon, Watson had sexual relations with her. He initially told a friend he had sex with the woman, but later said he was lying when he made that claim while under being questioned by investigators. He was 21 at the time of the incident.

A Faribault Daily News report from last May provides some context about the allegations, which could've landed Watson in prison for 30 years:
The girl said she had drunk eight beers in a two-to-three hour period and that she didn't remember anything after going to a public parking lot with friends at about midnight.

The girl said the next thing she remembers was being woken up on a futon in Watson's apartment at about 6 a.m. the next morning. She said she woke up in Watson's clothes but didn't remember changing at any point, and that she recalls her pelvic area being sore but didn't think anything of it because she was "so intoxicated," the report said...

Watson allegedly [later] told [a male] friend that he had touched the girl's genitals, performed oral sex on her, and had sex with her. Watson also reportedly said that the girl had said "no" several times and something to the effect of, "I can't do this," though Watson said he didn't stop.

The girl said she sent a text message to Watson after being told what happened and that he had responded by saying she wasn't that drunk and that everything was OK. He later sent another message saying that she was "so hammered" and that she "did not know what happened and could not remember anything."
The woman reported the incident to police, and a detective went to question him. Under questioning, Watson reportedly became agitated and told the detective, "This is shit. They always cry wolf!"

A Faribault Daily News report published yesterday details Watson acquittal on all counts:
Three of the charges against Watson involved allegations that the girl was physically helpless during the sex acts. The state argued that the girl was so intoxicated that she couldn't have given consent or non-consent that night...

The jury, made up of eight men and four women, deliberated for just two hours and came back with findings of not guilty on all four criminal sex conduct charges...

In an interview after the verdict was announced, [defense attorney Terry] Watkins said the case was a very important one, especially for younger people. He had argued that the girl had intentionally gotten drunk and then asked to stay at Watson's apartment.

"What we had here was voluntary, intentional intoxication ending in a rape trial," he said. "Rape is a horrible thing to go through, I understand that, but we have to be careful when rising to that level, when setting that standard."

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

Does City Pages have any editors on the staff?  I used to respect the quality of this publication (online and on paper), but lately every article seems to be grammatically and typographically labored with issues.  This article is no exception.   How about some quality control, CP?

Jason Bistodeau
Jason Bistodeau

So apparently...no means yes, but only if you're blackout drunk?

Rm Frankenstein Hanson
Rm Frankenstein Hanson

Whether he gives consent or non-consent, I hope he has his genitals slowly and violently removed. This is fucking disgusting. I hope the jury members never sleep again.

Brian Joseph Kanten
Brian Joseph Kanten

If this happened to my daughter there would be justice served!!!! It may not have been served in court this time but he would still get what he deserved!

Courtney Kuehn
Courtney Kuehn

"In an interview after the verdict was announced, [defense attorney Terry] Watkins said the case was a very important one, especially for younger people. He had argued that the girl had intentionally gotten drunk and then asked to stay at Watson's apartment." So Watkins believes that letting oneself get drunk and asking to stay at a friend's place is giving consent to be taken advantage of while being passed out? Where did he get his law degree and this makes me question how jurors are selected.

Jordan Iwan for Congress
Jordan Iwan for Congress

this is absolutely disgusting and reveals that we as a nation are not finished at the task of treating women equally and with respect. With regards to Taylor Watson he is among the lowest form of scum that resides within our borders, he is little more than an opportunistic predator and should be treated as such. once again our criminal justice system has failed us.


So what if, according to the defense attorney, "the girl had intentionally gotten drunk and then asked to stay at Watson's apartment." Does that mean she wanted to be raped? Staying at someone's apartment doesn't mean consenting to sex.


This sucks on so many levels.  Apparently it's okay to rape people when they aren't fighting back.

mingtran topcommenter

@GeekAaron : she got drunk and ASKED to stay at her creepy ex boyfriend's place... even if you are to argue that consent wasn't implied (remember, there's no scientific evidence anything actually took place), do you actually feel sorry for the little fool?

Now Trending

Minnesota Concert Tickets

From the Vault