Wisconsin paper defies police, publishes names of problem drinkers bars are asked not to serve

A recent Janesville Gazette story outed 10 of the city's most notorious problem drinkers.
The Janesville, Wisconsin, Police Department is taking a novel approach to dealing with 10 of the most notorious drunks in the city by putting together a "No Serve List" of folks bars in the city are asked not to serve.

SEE ALSO: Wisconsin newspaper censors "vagina" in Vagina Monologues ad [IMAGE]

While distributing the list to bars and the media, police attached a memo saying, "Do not distribute or post it publicly." But that didn't stop the Janesville Gazette from going ahead and splashing the 10 names on the front page of the paper last week.

Here, via the Romenesko journalism blog, is an image of the Gazette's front page story (click to enlarge):

drink.gif

As explained by the Gazette's story, each person on the list has had at least three "negative police contacts" while intoxicated in the past six months, including trips to jail or detox, all of which require the expenditure of taxpayer dollars.

"Your unwillingness or inability to drink responsibly is causing the Janesville Police Department to dedicate an unfair and unequal amount of resources to your habitual intoxication," reads the letter sent to the people on the list by police.

In an email, Janesville Police Department Deputy Chief Dan Davis told Romenesko, "Our preference would have been that the names wouldn't have been published [by the Janesville Gazette], but we have obligations under the open records law."

In his own email to Romenesko, Janesville Gazette editor Scott Angus was unrepentant about his paper's decision to run the names:
The police can request what they want, but we aren't an arm of law enforcement. We do what we think we should and what we think our readers expect and want...

Editors and the reporter discussed whether to use the names, and we couldn't come up with a good reason not to. That's generally our standard. Names are news, and we generally lean toward using them - unless there's a good reason to omit them...

Yes, publishing the names sets the 10 up for some amount of public ridicule, but so be it. They have been chronic abusers of public resources funded with tax dollars, and the police chose them for this list. We're just passing on the information. As an editorial we've written for this weekend states, maybe that ridicule will be what these people need to finally get help.
But as one commenter points out, perhaps the most surprising thing about this story is that a Wisconsin city with a population of more than 63,000 has only 10 names on its list of folks who drink way too much.

-- Follow Aaron Rupar on Twitter at @atrupar. Got a tip? Drop him a line at arupar@citypages.com.



Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help
13 comments
mairhart
mairhart

No formal police charges or convictions have been documented against the listed individuals. Since when are citizens guilty unless proven innocent, in the view of reputable news media?


Where in this article did the newspaper make an effort to distinguish between the accused individuals and innocent individuals who happen to have the same name?

I fail to see responsible journalism here -- just a reckless vendetta based upon hearsay. 

Jeremy Dowd
Jeremy Dowd

I'm glad to see there is a contingent of ladies represented as well as men--all of the DOT commercials about drunk driving only feature men--as a former bartender in Wisconsin I can vouch that men and women both have the potential to be disruptive when under the influence.

Josh Miller
Josh Miller

actually yes there has, a chronic alcoholic can die from quitting cold turkey.

Annette Marie Larson
Annette Marie Larson

That's a bold move, and speaks to freedom of the press and protecting the public. Kudos.

Tim Ward
Tim Ward

I liked this graf from the article: "But as one commenter points out, perhaps the most surprising thing about this story is that a Wisconsin city with a population of more than 63,000 only has 10 names on its list of folks who drink way too much."

Sizzle Pants Culp
Sizzle Pants Culp

Justin- as it's Janesville, it would make more sense for them to go to Illinois.

Nathan David Teegarden
Nathan David Teegarden

"The police can request what they want, but we aren't an arm of law enforcement" I wish more news outlets understood that.

Elfy Fett
Elfy Fett

That's excellent! Nothing bad ever happened to chronic alcoholics who were forced to go cold turkey.

Nicholas S. Goers
Nicholas S. Goers

You actually are posting something I agree with! First time for everything... ;)

Onan
Onan

@Josh Miller  - Your sarcasm detector seems to be broken.

Now Trending

Minnesota Concert Tickets

Around The Web

From the Vault

 

Loading...