Priest reportedly approached young men at Barnes & Noble, asked, "Are you fucking horny?"

Categories: Crime, Religion
CurtisWehmeyer.jpg
Curtis Wehmeyer
In the summer of 2012, Curtis Wehmeyer, a priest at Parish of the Blessed Sacrament in St. Paul, was charged with sexually abusing two boys and possessing child pornography.

SEE ALSO: So this is the homophobe who kept vandalizing gay-friendly Maple Grove church...

Wehmeyer's arrest came after the Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis reported allegations against him to police, and the church spun the story as one where they took quick and decisive action against an alleged pedophile priest. But if an in-depth MPR report can be believed, that was anything but the case.

According to MPR, reports of sexual misconduct involving Wehmeyer reached archdiocese officials as early as 2004, three years after he became a priest. In the spring of 2011, a high-ranking Catholic official wrote a memo to a colleague about how they should deal with the allegations.

Regarding an incident where Wehmeyer allegedly approached a man in a Borders bookstore and engaged in "suggestive conversation," Father Kevin McDonough, the archdiocese's "delegate for a safe environment," wrote that it was his belief Wehmeyer "was not all that interested in an actual sexual encounter, but rather was obtaining some stimulation by 'playing with fire.'"

"This sort of behavior would not show up in the workplace. I agree with Father Curtis that disclosure there would only serve to out his sexual identity questions (which, by the way, would be unlikely to surprise any observant person in the parish!)," McDonough continued, concluding that his recommendation "is that we encourage (or even require) Father Wehmeyer to disclose his pattern of self-destructive behavior to a small circle of trusted friends."

Seven years earlier, McDonough, then working as the archdiocese's vicar general, received his first report about Wehmeyer behaving inappropriately in a Twin Cities bookstore. MPR's report details that incident:
[In May 2004] Wehmeyer approached two young men ages 19 and 20 for sex at a Barnes & Noble store in Roseville. "It was really strange, the way he came on to us," one of the men, Andy Chapeau, said in an interview with MPR News.

Wehmeyer leaned close to one of the men and said, "Are you f--horny right now?"
A Catholic parishioner heard about the incident and brought it to McDonough's attention shortly after it occurred, but the church didn't take action. From MPR:
McDonough met with the concerned parishioner and one of the men approached by Wehmeyer at the bookstore. He assured them that Wehmeyer was receiving counseling. The parishioner wasn't satisfied with McDonough's answers, and he worried that he might hear about Wehmeyer in the news years later. When that happened, the parishioner wrote a furious letter to Nienstedt, the archbishop.
Despite numerous allegations of inappropriate conduct, Wehmeyer managed to keep his name out of the police blotter until June 2012, when he was charged with repeatedly abusing a 12-year-old boy his 14-year-old brother. One of the boys said Wehmeyer offered him cigarettes and beer, and showed him pornography. After he was abused, one of the brothers later abused both of his sisters. That abuse was reported to the boys' mother by one of the sisters.

MPR explains how the cycle of abuse was traced back to the priest:
The mother didn't understand how the boy could've learned about sex already. She asked him if he'd been watching pornography.

Yes, the boy said. Wehmeyer showed it to him.
Wehmeyer pleaded guilty and is currently serving five years in prison.

-- Follow Aaron Rupar on Twitter at @atrupar. Got a tip? Drop him a line at arupar@citypages.com.

My Voice Nation Help
19 comments
swmnguy
swmnguy topcommenter

When I first moved to the Twin Cities in 1986, I and my lovely lady at the time (I'll call we SE SD girl) were at the Target at Lyndale and Broadway North.  "Tar-Ghetto," as we called it (now I use that term for the Target at Lake St. E. and 26th Ave. S).  Ok, Ok.  We were young, broke, and our car could only go so far before it boiled over. Anyway, as we were checking out with whatever cleaning supplies and bug poisons we needed to make our slum $325/mo. efficiency apartment tolerable, this guy standing at the end of the checkout line muttered, "I'll do ya both..."  I pretended I didn't hear him and horsed "SE SD girl" and our stuff out the door and to our car with loud, off-putting boisterousness.  The guy didn't follow us, thank goodness.  I was pretty young and unaccustomed to that sort of conversation.

I had no idea he was probably a Catholic priest.

Keith Morris
Keith Morris

Not in Yemen they don't; an 8 year old girl recently bled to death after her 40 yr old "husband"/rapist had intercourse with her on their wedding night. I thought these same people committing these crimes were against "unnatural" sexual activities, except apparently when it comes to sex with children (of the opposite sex of course, which makes it totally OK). http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-24083127

Ross Levine
Ross Levine

Jon Waters was right, all the classy sex worthy men are readers..

Pinko Thinker
Pinko Thinker

your invisible skydaddy should really try a lot harder to discourage his favorite servants' idle compulsions, unless all of these incidents are prizes. at least the Muslims wait until after they're dead to perv on the powerless.

Ran Dazzle
Ran Dazzle

f the catholic church..bunch of perverts and haters..i don't have a minute for any of them

Tim Burkhardt
Tim Burkhardt

Does it ever end? Where's the transparency and honesty in the hierarchy and beyond? Sickening.

ThatGirl
ThatGirl

I love it when City Pages just summarizes another journalist's work instead of doing their own. Do it for the clicks!!!

LuteFisk
LuteFisk

Another Catholic molester, when is the Catholic church going to be dissolved? it is becoming clear that little boys is what they're in business for.

DanMitchell
DanMitchell

@dan_jsmith5551 @citypages I like the way you comment on stuff without bothering to read it. Also, there are Barnes & Nobles still open.

Onan
Onan

@ThatGirl  - You realize that this is a news aggregation blog, right??

Now Trending

Minnesota Concert Tickets

From the Vault

 

Loading...