Terrance Franklin wrongful death lawsuit makes explosive claims about racism in MPD

terrencefranklinrect.jpg
The MPD says it was self-defense. An attorney representing Franklin's family says it was murder.
A wrongful death lawsuit pertaining to the officer-involved shooting of Terrance Franklin on May 9 of last year alleges that racist cops executed Franklin, then engaged in a campaign intended to cover up their wrongdoing by publicly demonizing him.

The lawsuit, which is expected to be filed today, doesn't present much hard evidence to back up its explosive claims. Front and center to its case is the so-called "Gaines Video," a one-minute clip shot by someone standing across from the street from the south Minneapolis basement where Franklin was holed up as cops stormed the house. (Watch the video here.)

See also:
Motorcyclist lies dead in the street after hitting MPD squad during police chase [PHOTOS]

Mike Padden, the attorney representing Franklin's family, claims the video shows an officer calling Franklin a "Damn freakin' [N-word]," among other slurs. When the video was first trumpeted by Padden a few weeks after Franklin's death, Minneapolis Police Department Chief Janeé Harteau characterized the allegation officers used the N-word as "not only preposterous but without merit" and demanded an apology.

Here's the lawsuit's account of the circumstances surrounding Franklin's death:
During the time of the MPD SWAT team's interaction with [Franklin]... an MPD SWAT member, believed to be Defendant Lucas Peterson, called Franklin "little nigger" in the moments before Peterson and another SWAT member killed Franklin. Franklin presented no threat to the SWAT team since he had been successfully apprehended, clearly had surrendered, had both of his hands in the air at the moment he was killed in a surrender position, and was unarmed, but was killed, nonetheless, in an execution-type fashion due to anger, excessive force, and militarization.
That account, of course, stands diametrically opposed to the MPD's version, which holds that Franklin was killed after he got his finger on the trigger of a police MP5 submachine gun during a struggle and managed to shoot two officers in the legs before being gunned down himself. Last September a grand jury cleared officers of any wrongdoing, and two of them who were in the basement with Franklin on that May afternoon actually received a Purple Heart award.

Since it's basically a he said-she said situation, Twin Cities lawyer and legal expert Ron Rosenbaum says he doesn't think Padden has much of a case.

"Police misconduct cases are notoriously difficult cases to win and they're particularly difficult to win when they so-called victim also happens to be a guy with a criminal record, or a 'bad guy,'" Rosenbaum tells us. "In police misconduct cases society tends to give the benefit of the doubt in the extreme to police officers, for the simple reason that police officers have the extremely difficult job of dealing with the kind of people the public does not want to deal with, which is criminals."

"The standard in civil cases is 'preponderance of evidence'... It's a lower standard than a criminal case, but here you've got a guy with a criminal record, a guy who in the defendants' version was tied to a gun both at the site and with his DNA to another one, who was a suspect in a crime and ran while being questioned," Rosenbaum continues. "You've always got a high hurdle, but to turn that into a situation where a so-called 'bad guy' turns into a victim... And then you've got the kind of situation where it's hard to prove what happened [in the basement]. You might have two sides to the story but the other side is dead. Franklin can't testify."

Rosenbaum says he's surprised by the tone of Padden's lawsuit, which claims, for instance, that the "overall goal" of the MPD's racist culture "was to convey a theme to African Americans in Minneapolis that the City of Minneapolis was not '[N-word] friendly.'

(For more, click to page two.)



Advertisement

My Voice Nation Help
7 comments
TruDat
TruDat

The police chief should resign over this law suit. It was her rush to judgment and lies in front of the TV cameras that made all the speculation possible. And, of course a sleazy lawyer and corrupt judge will allow this case to go forward. 

Truth_Teller_1
Truth_Teller_1 topcommenter

I think the Minneapolis police department should pay the amount equal to the total wages this Thug has claimed on his 1040 forms.   What that?  You say he had no reported wages?   I guess then he's just a breeder.  

downtown
downtown

These same parents who are trying to sue the MPD should be sued for doing such a poor job of raising this kid. If my kid had a wrap sheet as long as this kid I would be embarrassed. 

Reid LeRud
Reid LeRud

the guy is a criminal the cops did the right thing

Ross Hassel
Ross Hassel

Don't you dare settle MPD. Nasty language boo hoo, I have a thug in my house. I'm pissed and say nasty things. The poor kid on the motorcycle that day is the victim. His parents should sue this thugs family.

Safetyfirst
Safetyfirst

Who cares if the cops are stupid pigs. They wasted a criminal scumbag and protected a homeowner. Give them all a medal.

Now Trending

Minnesota Concert Tickets

From the Vault

 

Loading...