Last 5 Weeks
« Previous Post | Main | Next Post »
A recent Star Tribune business story suggested sales have been up 25-30% in recent months at a couple of local "salvage" grocery stores, which cull food that mainstream supermarkets are ready to get rid of (often because it's expired or about to expire, the packages are damaged, or the marketing campaigns are over). I visited the So Low Grocery Outlet in north Minneapolis and Mike's Discount Foods in Hilltop and the Aldi on East Franklin to see how the shopping experience compared.
So Low is located at Lowry and Emerson in North Minneapolis, one of the city's most impoverished neighborhoods, but when I arrive, there are plenty of nice looking cars in the parking lot (along with a couple of MPD squad cars). While So Low isn't nearly as big as a mainstream supermarket, it does have all the requisite grocery departments: produce, meat counter, lots of packaged foods aisles (one devoted to ethnic foods), a refrigerator and freezer case.
The produce quality varies widely: some is ridiculously past its prime--several pineapple are so old they're mushy, and ears of corn are so dry you could make dolls from the husks and pop the kernels--while others, like the greens being misted with water, look just fine. At the meat counter, there's a range of steaks, ground beef, ribs, plus some inexpensive options, like fish heads, you don't see in most grocery shops. In the refrigerated area, there's yogurt that's expired a few days ago and turkey salad that's been past its prime for a week. I find a few examples of out-of-date marketing campaigns (Christmas and Fourth of July-themed Little Debbie snack cakes prices 2/$.99) and new products that perhaps sounded better to corporate marketing gurus than actual shoppers (Green Giant "immunity boost" vegetables and a "breakfast pizza" topped with scrambled eggs and bacon in the freezer).
Some prices seem on par with mainstream groceries, including milk and eggs, while others--an 18 oz. jar of Peter Pan peanut butter for $.99 and a 6-pack of diet IBC root beer at 2/$3--are significantly discounted.
My next stop is Mike's Discount Foods in a Hilltop strip mall (it's just west of Central, on 45th Avenue), which is significantly smaller, but equally busy. While So Low offered most staples, Mike's selection is more hit-or-miss: They're selling everything from grapefruit to generic SPAM to (expired) Yo Baby organic yogurt. The whole setup feels as temporary, like it could pack up and move to a new storefront overnight.
Aldi, on Franklin at Bloomington in South Minneapolis, looks the most like a mainstream grocery store or Costco. It's clean and well-lit, with wide aisles where boxed goods are stacked, not displayed on shelves. Aldi seems something like a low-cost Trader Joe's, where instead of selling gourmet items (goat cheese) at lower cost, they sell more mainstream items (American cheese) at even lower cost. Eggs and milk seemed a little cheaper at $1.45/dozen and less than $3/gallon. As with many generic-brand items, sometimes the quality is on par with popular brands and sometimes its inferior. They do sell some brand-name, unexpired foods that seem the same as in a mainstream grocery store, except cheaper.
All in all, there are deals to be had on discount groceries, but with gas at nearly $4/gallon, the savings are probably not significant enough to make a special trip. If the produce looks fine, it's probably not that different from conventional supermarket produce. I thought it was interesting that most of the bargain items weren't the nutritious staples price-sensitive shoppers need, and instead things like Ben & Jerry's Cake Batter ice cream, Dove chocolates in Christmas packaging. If you don't live near a discount grocery, you'll probably do just as well buying items that are on sale and clipping coupons.
Posted by Rachel Hutton at May 14, 2008 8:49 AM
« Galactic Pizza on CNN | Main | A Recipe for a Perfect Cheesy Weekend Getaway »
Call me a granny, but I live to clip coupons. My office gets the Sunday paper, so Monday morning I haul ass to our lunch room and house the coupons. It's a seriously easy way to save money, and it gets me to try products I otherwise wouldn't even pay attention to. I recommend it to everyone (except the people I work with, because I will strong-arm your asses on Monday).
Posted by: Granhopper Monica at May 14, 2008 2:12 PM
I think TJ's is owned by the same family that owns Aldi's.
Posted by: Juan at May 14, 2008 2:29 PM
Nice work thrifty. Plus you don't have to spend the buck and a half to buy the paper.
Posted by: Juan at May 14, 2008 4:15 PM
Aldi is not a salvage grocer! Even in the Strib article it is referred to as a "deep discount" grocery store. Aldi keeps prices low by carrying products under their own label, while still carrying some special brand-name items each week. I have never seen anything expired at Aldi!
That being said, I think that salvage grocery stores can be excellent resources for stretching grocery budgets. I live in St. Paul, where there are not as many (or any, it sometimes seems) sources for low-cost groceries. Driving over to Minneapolis can be daunting, due to gas prices and time constraints, but I've recently considered looking for (or starting) some sort of grocery ride-share program wherein community members share the costs of group transportation to various discount facilities.
In Minneapolis another great option for low-cost groceries is the Greater Lake Country Food Bank, 612-340-9694, located at 554 8th Ave N (by Olson Memorial Hwy and 7th st, near the Metro Transit facility). It is tiny but often has deep discounts on bulk items, and they offer (at least as of the last time I was there, in March 2008) free bread with a $10 purchase.
Of course, if you're really down on your luck or waiting for that next paycheck or food benefits payment to go through, there are always free options. Food shelves, contrary to popular belief, are not usually very easy places at which to receive services. For the Minnesota Emergency Food Shelf Network facilities there is a specific site for your geographic location (and not all food shelves are created equal so some neighborhoods offer facilities where patrons can choose their groceries and maintain some modicum of dignity while others may ask you your preferences but offer no input in the actual selection of items), you may only use the facility once per month (and receive 2-3 days worth of food), there are eligibility and qualification requirements, and you must provide constant proof of residence (not always easy if you are couch-hopping, homeless, move often, or cannot afford identification).
Some locations offer daily free bread (donated from local grocers and bakeries on a day-old basis), such as the West 7th Salvation Army in Saint Paul, and often suppliers donate other food items such as bakery treats, "fancy" breads, and sometimes even deli entrees and salads! Sharing and Caring Hands, in Minneapolis, has a need-basis (not geographic location) food shelf that is open several times per week, and they also offer free bread. That being said, a family (or poor college student;) ) can't live only on bread. Thus, it is worth it to combine shopping at regular, discount, and salvage grocers; finding food banks; utilizing food shelves, bread lines, and other free resources; and applying for benefits where eligible (although even if an individual or family qualifies for food support they can still expect to pay most of their food costs on their own)in order to fulfill their nutritional needs.
Posted by: Alex at May 21, 2008 10:56 AM
You're right, Alex, I was not clear about stating that So Low and Mike's have salvage items, whereas Aldi is simply a no-frills, discount grocer. Thanks for all the additional information you provided, too.
Posted by: Rachel Hutton at May 22, 2008 10:56 AM