The music magazine death rattle
- There are fewer superstars, and the same musicians show up on every magazine cover.
- Music mags have less to offer music lovers, and music lovers need them less than ever anyway.
- Music magazines were an early version of social networking. But now there's this thing called "social networking" ...
The value of the music reviewer has always been split between consumer service (should people plunk down cash for this CD?) and art criticism (what's the CD about?), but of late the balance has shifted from the former toward the latter--answering the question of whether to buy an album isn't much use when, for a lot of listeners, the music is effectively free. It's a valid point that the professional critic still wields an aura of authority rare in the cacophonous world of online music, but between taste-making blogs and ever-smarter music-recommendation algorithms like Apple Genius and Pandora, the critic's importance is being whittled down.All of which makes me wonder: Do people still rely on critics for tips on new music? Sure, there are millions of songs at a listener's fingertips at any given moment, but we still need to have people throwing down guideposts in all of this uncharted territory. Maybe those tour guides will crop up more and more in the form of music bloggers, message board users, and a listener's own personalized group of opiners (Twitter users, Facebook friends, etc). And while that's bad news for professional music critics, it seems to work out fine for listeners, at least in terms of short bursts of information and tips on new music.
But Weiner ends his article on a high note for us music writers, saying that while the internet may fill part of the void left my defunct print music magazines, we are still lacking in long-form, well-researched music essays and feature stories. "In the absence of the great feature writing that music magazines do underwrite," he says, "(and unless Web writing, video interviews, artists' blogs, and other new forms fill the void), we'll be hearing only part of the song."