Elite Gymnastics: 'There isn't a scene in Minneapolis'

elitegymnasticspromo.jpg
Ok, I'm convinced that Pitchfork is out to destroy Minnesotan artists' relationships with their hometowns. At least, that would seem to be the case given the recent hubbub over John Maus's record store-damning interview -- which Maus later retracted and said was misinterpreted and misleadingly edited -- and today's interview with Elite Gymnastics, which portrays the electro duo as... well, you be the judge. I think I'm done expounding on Pitchfork interviews with local artists for the summer.

Pitchfork: What's the music scene like in Minneapolis?

James Brooks: There isn't a scene. I feel like we wouldn't really fit in wherever we lived. We're just really weird people interested in really weird things. We have cats and girlfriends and sometimes we like to go to this torta place because they make really good tortas. As far as we're concerned, our musical home is the internet-- our points of view, lyrical style, and writing style all come from there.

Read the full interview here.


"Like" Gimme Noise on Facebook and follow us on Twitter at @gimme_noise.

My Voice Nation Help
17 comments
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Zach Pasdoe
Zach Pasdoe

Minneapolis doesn't have a music scene?  Try living in cities like Charlotte, Denver or most other cities of similar size.  The Minneapolis area does well among its peer metros (Seattle, Portland, Austin, and Nashville).  The remainder of "solid" scenes belong to larger cities / metros.  In other words, Minneapolis holds its own.

Jon
Jon

What?  Seattle, Portland and Austin's music scenes all destroy Minneapolis.  And come on, Charlotte is half the size of our metro area and Denver has a million less people.  Smaller cities have shittier scenes than our shitty scene?  My mind is blown.

Zach Pasdoe
Zach Pasdoe

What?  Minneapolis definitely holds its own against Seattle, Portland, and Austin.  For starters, name all the great bands currently coming out of each of these cities.  Seattle hasn't had an amazing scene since the 90s.  In regards to Portland, if one is into the the indie, hipster thing then, yeah it might have a cool scene.  Other than that Portland's scene doesn't destroy Minneapolis; not even close.  As far as Austin is concerned yes, it has the music events, one of which is becoming a commercialized joke.  Other than those events, how does Austin destroy Minneapolis.  Honestly, name the top 10 bands coming out of Austin right now. I bet you can't because Austin is one of the most overrated cities in the US, especially in terms of its local music scene.  Finally, in terms of city-proper population, both Charlotte and Denver are bigger than the city of Minneapolis and both are growing much faster in terms of city-proper and metro population.  They are both attracting a lot of young people.  That said, one would think each could put together decent, local scenes, but they haven't.

Jon
Jon like.author.displayName 1 Like

I do just love the image of this girl just getting this look of indignant, horrified shock as she read that line of the interview and then quickly put on Mumford and Sons

Jon
Jon like.author.displayName 1 Like

The only way I can explain this article is that Andrea Swensson has never lived in Chicago, New York, Athens or any number of other cities that actually have music scenes.  I mean it's just baffling.  If you call everyone listening to what the Current tells them to a music scene, well then I don't know what to tell you.  Minneapolis hasn't had a real music scene in 20 years.

But don't feel bad about it.  The concept of a vibrant localized music scene is fading rapidly in the Internet age.

Becky Lang
Becky Lang

draaaaama!

Yrtneg
Yrtneg

Only someone who thinks that Minneapolis has a music scene would consider this drama.

dude
dude

B Clarke, I may be off this is my opinion on it all, but I think they are simply getting influence from their core support/ interest/community on the internet...and that's intentionally broad I'm sure.. so again they view "scene" different than you.  to them there is no scene here in MN. I still don't think this is that shocking.   Minneapolis "scene" is not the source of pride (neutral to them at the very least) and this is odd to your average MN because so many people here are very proud of the music heritage here.. .which is fine but in my opinion this has made the "scene" kind of stagnant.  People look inward way too often - instead of exploring the world (or even "world wide web" as it's often known)  they WEB CRAWLASkeep it going CRAWLASenter some words, and start your search.  the Web Crawl.  doin the web Crawl.

Duder
Duder

I think there is certainly irony in this interview, just like there is irony in their music. Take it with a grain of salt. Also, ironic bands shouldn't exist.

Jae
Jae

Get back to me when you can shave, dumb ass

JM
JM

it kinda just sounds like they mean that they're not apart of any scene, rather then there being none at all. 

Ben Clark
Ben Clark

You guys make some good points and I think declining to partake in the usual boosterism is a valid position to take for a band like EG, who have found success appealing to the internet music community at large. But when asked "What's the music scene like in Minneapolis?" To answer that it simply doesn't exist is so blatantly false, regardless of your opinion of it's importance, it seems like a bit of a troll.

Guy
Guy like.author.displayName 1 Like

 Good point. I feel like he should have said, "There isn't a scene (for us)." But yeah, artists say dumb shit all the time, so nobody should take it too seriously.

dude
dude like.author.displayName 1 Like

I can relate to a large extent. this is no publicity stunt. they aren't even trying to be mean.  It's refreshing to have some honesty - mn people can't handle this and think it's some shocking shit. it's not.   Also, I see it as the internet is an international community of artists and producers that gives much more support than the mpls music scene for them.  they aren't influenced by bob dylan. or indie, social aware hip hop... and they don't get support from radio/media/big artists locally (until they were getting hyped of coure).. Why?  because there is no scene?  what's the controversy?  what's the big deal?  it is what it is

Guest
Guest like.author.displayName 1 Like

In their defense, having cats and girlfriends is super weird.

Guy
Guy

I think what he's saying is that, from their perspective, the very idea of a "scene" doesn't exist. A music scene is only real to the people who are part of that scene, and to a lot of those people (sadly) there is no world outside that scene. They can't wrap their heads around the idea that 99.9% of the world doesn't care about their "scene." That's not to disrespect the many fine musicians working in Mpls, but you have to admit that a lot of them are delusional wankers and hangers-on.

These chaps seem all right.

From the Vault

 

Minnesota Event Tickets
©2013 City Pages, LLC, All rights reserved.
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places Minneapolis / St. Paul

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city